Amy Bachman Cliett - As a practicing Board Certified Behavior Analyst, I have worked closely with parents, children of all ages, and adults on the spectrum for over a decade. Today was my surreal reality check. My son and only child came home from his first day of Kindergarten and told me every detail, down to the chocolate milk he had with lunch. Such a feat was years of hard work for the majority of families I know. My son is not fully vaccinated. Not yet, nor do I support him getting the flu shot or gardasil at age 10. Science may say no link, but the families I know say different. I am happy with my decision, it's the best one I felt I could make. And, it was interesting to watch 5 perplexed office staff silented on the first morning of school trying to figure out how to handle the religious exemption form =)
Jeff - I think it's perfectly appropriate for each parent to make their own decision. Although, I would caution any parent to do their own research before. I would start with actual studies. A lot of folks will represent what a study says. Take those reviews with a grain of salt. Some might disagree with me and suggest that if everyone doesn't get vaccinated than everyone will be at risk. (Herd Immunity). It took me awhile to get to the bottom of the herd immunity issue. Turns out the original thesis, written in the 30s, proposed that a population could come about immunity naturally. Vaccine proponents latched on to this concept by suggesting vaccines could provide this. However, there is a critical piece missing from that argument. There are two types of immunity. Humoral immunity (the creation of antibodies) which vaccines are 'intended' to provide and Cell mediated immunity where the cells themselves are impervious to the infection. Vaccines cannot provide cell mediated immunity. And without it, you're just inducing anti-body creation in the bloodstream, which doesn't--on its own--produce lasting immunity.
Melissa Jill :) - Clearly I am not claiming to be an expert, Shannon. I am just bringing awareness to a debate that does exist and is alive and well. There are smart people on both sides of the debate and everyone deserves to know the claims of both sides in order to make a decision for themselves.
Shannon - Love this quote: "I think it is naïve for a parent [or a loving aunt] to think that she can become an expert on vaccines by spending some time on the Internet, reading questionable sources, almost all of which have some agenda. I accept that I can’t know everything, and I have enough faith in humanity that I trust others who know more than me."
from:
http://www.doublexscience.org/2012/08/on-parenting-science-and-trust.html?spref=tw
Mitzi Cook - My 10 year-old-son was a normally developing baby until vaccines at age two, when his speech stopped. At 3-1/2 he was hospitalized for fifteen weeks with pancreatis. After detoxing his body, speech came back and slowly he regained his ability to communicate. We're still dealing with ASD, but I'm definitely in the second camp.
Patti Van Butkleo - I don't know what to think about all of the vaccine controversies. I do believe that te only reason we administer several viral loads at once to young children is because physicians know they will see children early in life but not as much as they grow older, hence, the load. My oldest received 13 vaccines with severe reactions to the DPT...did research before the Internet at the library and learned at that time, pertussis might be causing his problems. We did not give him another one. My youngest, born, 11 years later, has received 39 vaccines. It is just nuts.
Sunny - "Vaccines are easy to give, fairly inexpensive, and provide protection from widespread infection. "
Disagree with the last line. There is NO proof that they work at all. What works, and had numbers of infectious diseases down LOW before widespread vaccination became available is cleaner drinking water and good sanitation.
What has also worked to ELIMINATE autism (aka heavy metal toxicity) in my vaccine damaged son is low dose frequent chelation. Remove the metals, remove the disorder.
cia parker - Denise,
I just read your post and it moved me deeply. I haven't read about many parents saying that their child lost his language right after vaccination, the way ours did. (Sonja Hintz, in "A Mother-Son Story," in Vaccine Epidemic, is the only other one I can think of.) I can't say how much my daughter's condition (autism, with poor language skills, cognitive development, and social skills) was caused by the encephalitic brain damage caused by the hep-B vax and how much by that fateful DTaP booster. Maybe the other vaccines she got too, three other DTaPs, three Hibs, and three polios. I only can speak confidently about the extreme reactions caused by those two vaccines. And I don't know what to do now. She's been in speech therapy for six years, and she's nowhere close to normal in speaking.
cia parker - I recommend that you (and everyone else) read the book The Age of Autism, by Dan Olmsted and Mark Blaxill. They document the beginnings of autism exhaustively, the first documented cases were in the late 1930s, Dr. Leo Kanner examined about ten children who had showed the distinctive signs of autism, and in his article on them in 1943, he said it was a condition never before seen or described anywhere, and all of the children had had dangerous levels of exposure to mercury, whether in the diphtheria vaccine or the mercury-laden fungicides their parents were working on developing. My daughter reacted to the hep-B vaccine at birth with four days and nights of inconsolable screaming, vaccine-induced encephalitis, and was later diagnosed with autism. The vaccine had mercury, even though a federal commission a year before had said the vaccine was dangerous and should not be used with mercury in it. I screamed for days after getting the DPT vaccine as an infant, and have Asperger's syndrome now.
The flu vaccine still has mercury, and the MMR often causes autism even though it is a live vaccine, and doesn't have mercury or aluminum.
Completely unvaccinated children have autism at a vanishingly rare rate, one Amish boy living near a mercury-producing electrical plant has autism, some other children contaminated by industrial or agricultural heavy metals, but by far the greatest cause is vaccines. Since the damage is often not immediately apparent, many parents don't put together the chain of causal events. Lucky us. For us it was obvious. My daughter had painstakingly started saying two words by the time she was 18 months old, uh for up and uff for dog, but both words disappeared forever as soon as she got a DTaP booster shot at that age, and she didn't say another word until 34 months old.
Vaccines have damaged several generations now, not just with autism, but with asthma, allergies, bowel disease, ADHD, learning disorders, seizure disorders, paralysis and MS (that last is what happened to me). Everyone should read exhaustively about the dangers of every vaccine before they consider getting it, and than they'll probably decide against it.
Ginger - Melissa, You are so courageous! As is your sister and her husband!
I know no one knows what causes Autism, it should be a top priority to find out! My 6-yr old daughter has never been vaccinated, (I guess that makes her or me leeches in some people's eyes). When I needed to find a pediatrician for my daughter (before she was born) I interviewed many, but found that the one who respected my views and was at least open to an altered or delayed vaccine schedule was from Britain. I am not throwing all vaccines under the bus. I just think we need more info and research. And personal responsibility to get educated and personal freedom to make the decision for our family. After all vaccines are designed to help and not hurt. Also I would love to see more focus on strengthening our immune system. If we are going to subsidize things, why not healthy foods, probiotics, and supplements. I totally agree on the food comments posted as well. The way we live today is so much more toxic than our ancestors. I have an auto-immune "disease" and am Celiac as well. These are not things traditional medicine can fix, or even explain. If I have a broken arm or am in a car wreck, I can guarantee you I will be in a hospital in a NY minute. I am not down on Doctors or medicine. I like many have shaped by my experiences. People who become advocates and forge a new path do not choose it, they are chosen. 1 in 67 affected is unacceptable by anyone's standards. We can do this. Together. Much love to all of you affected by Autism, you are in my prayers!
Mique - I commented before on how much I am LOVING this series you are doing. I think you put my thoughts down exactly in this post. As an autism momma this debate is an important one. My oldest (he's now 10) has the full vaccination schedule- he was diagnosed at 2. I have a daughter who is 8 and a son that is 4 that had no vaccines and they have no signs of ASD. Thanks Melissa! ;)
A Brown - While I won't share my opinions on all vaccines as a pediatrician I did want to address Erin's comments about chicken pox. Although relatively rare there is a severe encephalitis that can occur and has a 5-20% fatality rate. I have also seen numerous children with cancer whose immune systems are depleted get severe cases of chicken pox that would likely have been prevented by the vaccine (or catching the disease prior to having cancer). The vaccine should also prevent shingles from occuring which happens frequently to people who have caught chicken pox. Finally if a pregnant woman is exposed to someone with active chicken pox her fetus can be affected and even die in utero. So, while it's easy to think that since most of us had no problems with chicken pox our kids won't that's not necessarily always the case.
Erin Smith - When I had my first child a year ago, this was a topic I really wrestled with. Of course, I wanted to make the best decision for my child. I certainly didn't want to give him anything that could attribute to autism, but I also didn't want to leave him exposed to horrible diseases. In the end, I found a wonderful pediatrician whom we discussed all of this with, and we agreed to do a delayed/selective schedule. We follow the Dr. Sears schedule, but not to an exact T. Some vaccines we will skip all together - such as chicken pox. What the heck - I mean I had chicken pox, everyone I know had the pox, and I don't know one single person who had a bad reaction to it.
In the end, I don't know if there is a right answer. All I can do is make the best informed decisions I can make for my child.
Kelly Lawson - Thank you so much! I tend to always rely on doctors and treat their word as gold, but the more I read the more I realize that this isn't the safest mindset. I happen to catch a Doctors episode on Autism that Jenny McCarthy was on, it's what woke me up to the way I look at doctors and the way they approach medicine. I'm not sure if you've seen this episode, the younger doctor totally lost his temper with a man that suggested that there was a link between Autism and vaccinations. Even tho the younger doctor was saying that they (doctors) were doing what they knew were to be 'right and correct' I could see the frustration in his face, I wasn't buying his rant. I believe that doctors are doing what they think are right, by the book, but the book has been very wrong before. I swear the FDA approves just about everything that crosses their desk, then waits to see the outcome.
I look forward to next weeks post!
tami - perfectly put....i couldn't agree with you more on the debate. well written.
again, thank you for sharing such imperative information that i think if often overlooked .
Desiree - I find Audra's comments fascinating. I do sometimes wonder if we aren't poisoning ourselves. I felt like after the oil spill in the gulf that we are slowly self destructing. Could it be on more levels then we think?
Audra Little - One more comment..
They did a research on the Amish population.. they don't immunize or use chemicals in their food.. not one case of Autism. They did think they had one, but after researching the history they found out he was adopted.... makes you wonder...
Audra Little - I am an SLP as well as a photographer.. My life is surrounded by children with autism. My first daughter received her vaccinations, after a heated debate with my pediatrician, and developed sensory issues. She received both speech and OT for her sensory delays. My second daughter is 9 months old and has yet to receive immunization. I am for immunizations, just not until their immune system can handle it... I also am a firm believer that food is also the culprit. Since we have started genetically altering our food in the 80s, Autism has risen 600%, ADHD is like 200%, cancer is also increasing. Researchers call it the "perfect storm"---food +immunizations + genetics.. a recipe for Autism. I just hope that some day they figure it all out. A very good movie about food is Food, inc. It's scary
Andi Watson - Thank you so much for sharing this! Both of my children were vaccinated as infants/toddlers, but after my son was vaccinated while suffering pneumonia and RSV, I had some misgivings about these methods. He wasn't officially diagnosed as autistic until he reached elementary school age. My daughter, while still vaccinated, was done so on a less aggressive schedule with many more questions asked and was never vaccinated above or beyond the minimum requirement for public school. I cannot advocate enough how necessary it is for parents to ask questions and become educated before allowing ANY chemicals or pharmaceuticals to be administered to their children.
Melanie - The vaccine debate is definitely a hotly contested subject. I feel that vaccines are very important for our children, BUT I know that it could be done in a better way. The whole point of vaccinating a large percentage of children is to provide 'Heard Immunity', thus offering protection against disease by the masses being vaccinated and protecting the weak, who cannot be vaccinated. Do I think ALL children should be vaccinated? No. If your child has a weakened immune system or neurological problems, then vaccines ought to be reevaluated. There should be some sote of testing that is done on children to determine who is and who is not a good candidate for vaccines. Also, I believe the dosing schedule should be spaced out more. I remember bringing my 2 mo in for shots and him getting 5. That just seems like a bit much. I think an alternative dosing schedule should definitely be more readily available without the criticism of any medical professionals. Finally, for those children who ARE healthy and have no medical issues, they should definitely be receiving vaccines to protect those who are medically unable. Whatever stance you take, I think we can ALL agree that more research needs to be done, as Autism is becoming more and more common in the 21st century and the cause needs to be found so we can treat this epidemic.
Rachael Earl - I wholeheartedly agree with you-I have never met a child with autism who was not vaccinated. We get a lot of flack from hospitals, doctors, and most recently school nurses for not vaccinating our children, but we can't justify injecting our newborns with several diseases at once (not to mention the mercury, metals, and formaldihyde that are in them). Several doctors have told me that they give vaccinations as infants simply because it is the easiest age, with the least amount of protest. You can very easily tell your medical professionals that you do not wish to have your child vaccinated in the hospital, and can sign a waiver form stating it is against your beliefs when you register them for school.
Jen Pecasting - Melissa, your nephews are adorable!
I have one vaccinated son who is on the Asperger's spectrum and one unvaccinated son who shows no signs of Autism or Asperger's. I realize this is FAR, FAR from any sort of scientific study, but it IS the reality in my household. I personally think every immune system reacts differently to toxins (from vaccines and other sources - such as high fructose corn syrup which contains mercury) and our little ones are bombarded with so many of them these days - some just can't handle it.
Thank you again for sending me Mother Warrior's. I found it particularly interesting what McCarthy had to say about Aluminum. It made me pick up my book about vaccines by Dr. Sears and he has some interesting things to say about aluminum as well, and also formaldehyde. Btw, I passed the book on to a friend whose son was diagnosed with Autism last month.
Mary - I can assure you that I am not mis-remembering my son's reaction to the MMR shot. He was given it at his twelve month check up and his 13th month of life remains one of the most difficult months of my life.
Please keep up the posts Melissa. Information is the best weapon we have to fight for our children. Your nephews are so blessed to have you in their corner.
Myndi B. - Wow, I am blown away by the number of people who have responded so positively to this post, Melissa. I thought we were completely in the minority- and I know we still are, but as parents who have made the choice not to immunize, we have sought out open-minded pediatricians for Ty as well as having his main doctor be an ND so we wouldn't have to go through the process of all the questioning about our very informed decision. He's never even had (or needed) so much as a baby aspirin, and Ty's Dr. in NH said the only immunization he wanted us to reconsider, since he still sees cases of it, was whooping cough. That stunned me- that so many Drs insist you're doing your child harm if you decline the series of shots, but that this Dr. said he really didn't think they were all necessary either. People just need to ask more questions, do their own research, and follow their inner feelings when it comes to what's best for their children and their bodies. I love that you're posting so openly on this very controversial topic. :o)
robyn campbell - I'm so glad you are discussing this. I too totally agree with you. Thanks for being so open and honest with your opinion...it's nice to hear! I'm looking forward to your next post.
cameron clark | c+k studios - I'm with you! Neither of my kids has been vaccinated, and before other people lay into me for this, I do plan on doing some on my own time schedule. Mostly I object to the massive amount of vaccines in small infants. It's a tough topic, but as a society we need to realize one important thing: humans get sickness and disease and for the most part we can fight it and be healthier for it (and immune to it naturally). By introducing strange toxins into perfectly good 6-week old blood streams, we take a calculated risk. The question I ask the medical community is, "How calculated is that risk?" The answer is "they don't really know." Medicine affects every human and especially every baby differently. How can you prescribe the SAME drug/vaccine to a population of millions of different tiny bodies? You are bound to see part of that population suffer (and we have). Vaccines is an EXTREMELY reactive industry (vs preventative). They are using your child as a guinea pig. If you tell me Autism and vaccines isn't related, then please explain to me the DRASTIC increase in children with these problems. It's not normal, it's not historical and it's not because it was "under reported" in past years. Until some good science emerges, I tell parents to plead with your pediatrician for some answers and solutions/alternative schedules. If there was a mandatory vaccine reaction statistic, I'd be a lot happier camper and all parents could make better decision. Wouldn't it be nice to know that 20% of all children have a reaction to X vaccine?
denise karis - oh melissa, this is actually one ive been waiting for. My son was starting to say words at 14 months and then he got some shots and he didnt say anything else until he was three. now hes in speech therapy and the whole thing has made me super sad and paranoid and then when I went back to the doctor and expressed my concern, they acted like i was crazy. UGH. So frustrating. I am with you here.
elena - I am actually of the opinion that the vaccines are totally useless and unneeded. I grew up oversees with having perhaps only 5 vaccinations all my life, where as in the US kids get over 30+ shots by the age of 2-3. It is super madness. It is a money making machine. Most vaccines were not even developed until AFTER the plague [of whatever origin] had already run its course and was on the decline. The ingredients in the vaccines are most undesirable and scary, and there is mostly not regulation on how they are made.
I pray that your nephews recover and their well being improves, Melissa.
April - Thanks Melissa for your continued posts on autism. As of now, we are not affected by autism, but as a mother of 2 under 3 years old, we're highly affected by the world of rapid vaccinations! The only way it will change is if more people begin to speak out about all of it. So I truly appreciate your strong stance and willingness to speak out, even if it's not the popular opinion! Blessings!
Mary - Melissa, these are definitely some excellent posts you've been having about autism. To be honest, I don't know one way or the other whether or not vaccines have anything to do with causing autism. But simply the fact that many parents reported noticing their child's behavior change after getting a vaccination is not any sort of proof. To cite the recent findings about the Toyota accelerator/break issue. They've now found that in 100% of the cases where people INSISTED they were pushing the brake instead of the accelerator (and the car had a recorder box), they were wrong. The car's recorder box showed no sign that the brake was pushed.
So, people often in full faith mistakenly remember things. That's not to say vaccines don't cause autism...just that people's memory is not really the best evidence. Yes, even intelligent, observant people can mistakenly remember or associate something. I'm sure it's happened to you before!
Of course, it's a very difficult disorder to understand, so I can't blame anyone for taking precautions. I'm sure I'll have to cross that bridge when I come to it, too. I would just like to see more scientific evidence one way or the other.
Thanks again for the wonderful posts!
Charlie - Definitely with you in the second camp here Melissa.
Not sure if you've read "House Rules" by Jodi Picoult - about a kid who has autism - pretty interesting read :)